Dexter Original Sin: An Honest Review
[SPOILER ALERT]
Dexter Original Sin has arrived, and it’s time to slice into this highly anticipated prequel. Fans of Dexter have been eager to explore this new take on our favorite Dark Passenger. But does Dexter Original Sin live up to the hype? Or is this prequel just a pale imitation of its predecessor? Let’s dive in.
A Hollow Echo of the Original
The first episode of Dexter Original Sin feels like a caricature of the iconic series. Young Dexter, with his long locks, looks more like Jesse Eisenberg than Michael C. Hall. Even when he trades in the hair for a shorter style, he lacks the brooding presence of the original Dexter Morgan.
The intro? A blatant copy-paste of the original series. It’s nostalgic, sure, but it screams “lazy.” And is it just me, or is the apartment identical to Dexter’s adult home? In the flashbacks from the original series, didn’t they live in a house?
The Casting Conundrum
Casting is where Dexter Original Sin falters the most. Let’s start with Harry Morgan. Christian Slater? Really? While his performance wasn’t terrible, it lacked the gravitas and complexity that James Remar brought to the role.
Then there’s young Debra Morgan. She’s shorter, stockier, and her features don’t align with Jennifer Carpenter’s. Sure, Deb had a potty mouth, but forcing that trait into a younger version of her character feels clunky.
Patrick Dempsey as Captain Aaron Spencer is perhaps the biggest miss. His portrayal feels more like a Saturday Night Live parody than a genuine attempt at the role. Overacted, underwhelming, and wholly unconvincing.
Young Batista fares no better. Instead of a believable younger Angel, he looks like an “Ozempic version” with fake facial hair. On the bright side, young Masuka brings some humor, nailing Masuka’s iconic laugh, though he too falls into overacting.
Some Bright Spots
Not all is lost. Sarah Michelle Gellar as Tanya Martin stands out as a rare high point. Her performance feels natural and refreshingly grounded. Similarly, young Camilla shows potential, though her screen time was brief.
A Prequel or a Parody?
The biggest issue with Dexter Original Sin is its tone. Instead of capturing the dark, nuanced world of Dexter’s early years, it feels like a cheap soap opera. It reminded me of Supernatural’s self-parody episodes, but the difference is Supernatural aimed for laughs. Here, we’re supposed to believe these are the genuine early years of beloved characters.
Final Verdict
For die-hard fans like me—someone who’s rewatched the original series countless times—Dexter Original Sin is a letdown. I’ll give it a generous 3.5/10, but unless episode two takes a dramatic turn, my expectations are low.
Have you watched Dexter Original Sin? Did it butcher your expectations or leave you craving more? Comment below and share your thoughts!
This blog contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you click on a link and make a purchase or sign up for a service. This comes at no additional cost to you and helps support the content on this site. I only recommend products or services I believe in or that I think will be valuable to my readers. Thank you for your support!
Facebook Comments